Some celebrities seem to have discovered the secret to eternal youth, retaining their remarkable beauty from years past. Take Halle Berry, whose ageless complexion has left fans in awe, or Sofia Vergara, whose flawless allure appears untouched by time. These nine stars have managed to preserve their stunning looks as if they’ve barely aged a day since their careers began.

22 years ago, at the age of 36, Halle Berry starred in Die Another Day. Remarkably, she appears to have hardly aged since then.

At 43 years old, the singer appears even more youthful in recent photos than she did in her 20s.

Brad Pitt was 35 years old when he acted in the movie Meet Joe Black.

Salma Hayek was 30 years old when she starred in the movie From Dusk Till Dawn in 1996.

Jennifer Connelly was 16 when she acted on the movie Labyrinth in 1986.

Jennifer Lopez was 28 years old when she played the singer Selena Quintanilla in 1997.

Winona was 17 years old when she appeared in the movie Beetlejuice in 1988.

Michael Keaton was 41 when he portrayed Batman and 65 when he appeared in The Founder.

The Modern Family star appears to have stopped aging back in her 30s.

Meanwhile, online users have created their own list of the most attractive people over the age of 40, with some spots even being shared by multiple celebrities.